Want Starmer out? Vote Labour. Think he should stay? Vote Reform. My poll proves it's a funny old world: LORD ASHCROFT

Published: 22:32, 30 May 2026 | Updated: 22:40, 30 May 2026 With the launch of Andy Burnham's by-election campaign, Britain entered a sort of political limbo. Only six people in a hundred think Keir Starmer will still be Prime Minister after the next election, but even more uncertain is whether he will still be in No 10 in a few weeks – and if not, who will? The electors of Makerfield find themselves in an unusual position. Those who want to oust the PM and bring down the Labour Government in its current form will have to vote… Labour.  Any who think Starmer is unfairly maligned, is doing a reasonable job in impossible circumstances and deserves more than two years in office after a decade and a half of the Tories (and such people exist in greater numbers than you might think) would be best advised to vote for Reform UK. It is, as the philosopher said, a funny old world. We will know in just over a fortnight if the Wigan constituency has agreed to serve as the vehicle for Burnham's ambition or whether – from despair with Labour, the lure of Reform or sheer British bloody-mindedness – they decide to throw a spanner in the works.  There is, after all, something about the spectacle of politicians carving things up among themselves that rubs people the wrong way ('it would be very funny if he didn't get in,' chuckled someone in my focus groups last week). If Makerfield declines to comply, the threat to Starmer persists. Wes Streeting has declared his intentions, after all. In my groups, those who had a view of Streeting at all rather liked him.  Sir Keir Starmer meets apprentices at the Acton Works training facility in Chiswick, west London on May 28, 2026 The findings of Lord Ashcroft's latest poll present some paradoxical findings for Britain's voters He seemed to them less argumentative and more approachable and 'normal' than most politicians, although some wondered if a 'nice man' was what Britain needed at the moment.  For those with better things to do than follow the political soap opera, he was a blank page ('I only heard of him on the news on the way here just now,' another remarked). Angela Rayner, also a possible contender if Burnham is sent packing to his mayoral parlour, continues to provoke strong views on both sides. But if she thinks being cleared by HMRC over her £40,000 stamp duty underpayment is the same thing as being cleared by the voters, I fear she is mistaken.  'She lost her job because of the tax dodge, and suddenly she's back in like it never happened!' observed one of our participants.  Others sensed a stitch-up: 'They don't clear anybody normally, do they, once HMRC get hold of you. That wouldn't happen for a normal person if they hadn't paid their taxes.' The mistrust lingers. Rayner's supporters would no doubt point to Green leader Zack Polanski, his apparent failure to pay council tax while living on a houseboat and the bizarre embellishments to his employment history.  Green partisans, in turn, would deflect the conversation to Nigel Farage and his £5million gift from crypto entrepreneur Christopher Harborne, which would prompt Reform UK enthusiasts to revive tales of PPE contracts for Conservative cronies, and so it goes on. As we have seen time and again with Donald Trump, partisans are unmoved by their heroes' flaws, not least because they care more about what they will do than about how they behave. Andy Burnham, Labour's candidate in the Makerfield by-election, attends a traditional Saturday breakfast club in Ashton-in-Makerfield to meet with retired miners and local organisers on May 30, 2026  The main effect of these stories is that outsiders hoping to seem new and different soon look like any other politician. My polling finds both Streeting and Rayner behind Kemi Badenoch in the best PM stakes, while Burnham would lead by 13 points. If Makerfield says yes to Burnham, a successful challenge to Starmer has become the expectation. But then what? Just under four in ten Labour voters – a fair chunk, but by no means all – think the Government would change for the better if Starmer were replaced. In my groups, impressions of Burnham tend to be positive; people say his administrative experience, election-winning record and evident popularity must count for something.  But for voters as a whole, the most likely outcome of a change of Labour leadership is that things will continue pretty much as they are.  Tony Blair won't be thanked for pointing out that Labour's problem is not the personality of its leader but that it lacks a 'worked-out, coherent plan for the country' (the party will seemingly never forgive him for being the most successful leader in its history), but he's right. Not only that, people fear a resumption of the endless leadership circus they thought they had thrown out with the Tories. Angela Rayner is seen during a reception for homelessness charities and organisations who played an influential role in bringing forward the Renters' Rights Act, at 10 Downing Street on May 19 This is also part of the reaction when we talk about rejoining the EU, as favoured by Streeting and once (until he had a Brexit-voting constituency to contend with) by Burnham.  Just over half say life in Britain since we left has been worse than if we had stayed, and the same proportion said they would vote to return. But dig deeper and there is little appetite to restart the Brexit wars, or to comply with the likely conditions. A clear majority oppose adopting the euro, a legal prerequisite for countries seeking to join. Even more say it would be unacceptable to pay the higher membership fee that Brussels would surely demand. The parallels between Brexit and the Labour leadership are striking. Rejoining the EU is no more the answer to Britain's woes than replacing Starmer is the answer to Labour's. Neither addresses the real problems: an unproductive economy and a state that spends more than the country can afford. The leader who grapples with those things – from whichever party – will deserve to win. Lord Ashcroft is a businessman, philanthropist, author and pollster. His research is at LordAshcroftPolls.com. No comments have so far been submitted. Why not be the first to send us your thoughts, or debate this issue live on our message boards. By posting your comment you agree to our house rules. Do you want to automatically post your MailOnline comments to your Facebook Timeline? Your comment will be posted to MailOnline as usual. Do you want to automatically post your MailOnline comments to your Facebook Timeline? Your comment will be posted to MailOnline as usual We will automatically post your comment and a link to the news story to your Facebook timeline at the same time it is posted on MailOnline. To do this we will link your MailOnline account with your Facebook account. We’ll ask you to confirm this for your first post to Facebook. You can choose on each post whether you would like it to be posted to Facebook. Your details from Facebook will be used to provide you with tailored content, marketing and ads in line with our Privacy Policy. The heartbreaking secret Rachel Nickell took to her grave, revealed by her partner and son in the most intimate interview they've ever given