Newcastle, Nick Woltemade and the ongoing pursuit of attacking balance

AFC BournemouthArsenalAston VillaBrentfordBrighton & Hove AlbionBurnleyChelseaCrystal PalaceEvertonFulhamLeeds UnitedLiverpoolManchester CityManchester UnitedNewcastle UnitedNottingham ForestSunderlandTottenham HotspurWest Ham UnitedWolverhampton WanderersScores & ScheduleStandingsFantasyThe Athletic FC NewsletterPodcastsAnalysisNewcastle, Nick Woltemade and the ongoing pursuit of attacking balance George Wood/Getty Images Share articleGame number 56 of Newcastle United’s season and their 36th in the Premier League. Mercifully, this draining, marathon campaign is almost over. Worryingly, it looks set to end with Eddie Howe still scrambling around for attacking balance, still struggling to piece together the parts of his offensive jigsaw, and still unable to extract the most from Newcastle’s £64million ($87.2m) club-record signing. Longer term, Nick Woltemade may yet prove to be the answer — a vocal section of the fanbase certainly believe he is — but right now he encapsulates Newcastle’s wider attacking flaws. What Woltemade is, where he fits in and how he will succeed on Tyneside all remains opaque. If anything, we have actually moved further away from being able to answer those questions. So much uncertainty hangs over Newcastle heading into the summer. Whether Woltemade is a critical part of a radical solution or a misfit stylistically who will never be suited to ‘Howe-ball’ — if the head coach even remains at the club — is a call which still needs to be made. The evidence so far suggests that, unless Howe deviates significantly from his present approach or actively recruits players who can complement Woltemade’s technical qualities, the 24-year-old is not the lone centre-forward who can lead the line in a 4-3-3. None of Woltemade’s last 14 top-flight starts, stretching back to January 18, have been as a striker. Instead, Woltemade has been deployed as a makeshift No 8 — unfairly, some argue, and to limited effect — or left on the bench, with only four starts across the previous 13 Premier League games. His last two top-flight starts, against Sunderland in March and Sunday’s 1-1 draw at Nottingham Forest, have been as a second striker. Woltemade looks more comfortable picking up the ball in the pocket, able to turn and play in his team-mates, rather than receiving possession with his back to goal as a centre-forward. But it is not as if Woltemade has made an incontrovertible case for Howe to persist with him as a No 10. That is harsh on Woltemade because he has not been afforded a long-enough run there so he can really exert influence, yet the same lack of game-defining interventions which saw him dropped as a striker (once the goals dried up following a flurry of seven in his first 14 Premier League games) remains in that deeper position. Woltemade, as always, delivered some lovely moments at the City Ground — a strong run and pass to play in Will Osula who should have scored, a delicious ball to release Jacob Murphy on the wing, and a lung-busting recovery run to dispossess Dilane Bakwa on the edge of the Newcastle box — but there were once again too few in the final third. During his 61 minutes on the pitch, the German did not manage a shot, created two opportunities (one defined by Opta as a “big chance”) and had only 21 touches. Of those, just two were in the opposition box, the same as Yoane Wissa enjoyed during his 19-minute cameo. “For Nick, it was one of a handful of times he’s played that role for us from the start with Will, and they haven’t played together too much,” Howe told reporters afterwards. “I thought there were some promising bits. “We probably didn’t get him involved as much as we wanted to. Certainly, technically, we need to see his best qualities, to see him on the ball. “Second half, we did really well as a team, we improved and became more of goal threat as the game went on.” Whether that final sentence represented a critique of Woltemade, praise of the attacking replacements, or a mixture of both is something fans will likely interpret differently depending on how they feel about the German and Howe. Ramsey and Harvey Barnes injected pace and directness off the bench, combining excellently for Newcastle’s 74th-minute opener, with the former’s turn and pinpoint pass laying on the latter. Although Newcastle controlled large spells, they were more threatening during the second half, with 11 of their 16 shots and five of their six efforts on target, as well as 1.0 of their 1.54 expected goals (xG) coming after the break. Barnes’ cool finish aside, though, they once again lacked a clinical edge. Osula rattled the crossbar with a free kick, but he mishit a volley wide and should have converted when Woltemade played him in. Wissa looks woefully short of sharpness and confidence. Newcastle have scored just 17 goals in 17 away games this season, a tally higher than only three other Premier League sides. Last season, Alexander Isak scored 12 alone on the road in all competitions. “The best way to defend a lead is to grow it. We’ve done that really well historically and ended up winning games with big scorelines,” Howe said. “But we haven’t done that well enough this year. (With) a one-goal lead, it takes one mistake to cost you — and that’s what happened.” That combination of profligacy and poor defending is extremely damaging. Newcastle have kept one clean sheet in their last 22 games in all competitions, and just three in 29 in the Premier League. Another soft late concession — the 20th Newcastle have shipped in the final 15 minutes of top-flight matches this season — felt exasperatingly familiar. It was particularly “painful”, as Howe described it, because Elliot Anderson, the Newcastle academy product they reluctantly sold, was the scorer of the 88th-minute equaliser. With a staggering 27 points dropped from winning positions across 2025-26, no other Premier League side comes close to ceding the initiative when winning. Bournemouth are second with 20. Evidently, change is required with Howe admitting he has a “duty” to “see what the team is going to look like” for 2026-27. That is partly why the left-footed Lewis Hall deputised at right-back and Kieran Trippier, who is leaving, did not start. But Howe also implied to BBC Radio Newcastle that was also why the fit-again Anthony Gordon did not play. With an exit appearing highly likely for Gordon, he will not form part of Newcastle’s attacking formula next season. Whether Woltemade will, and in what capacity, is unclear. Spot the pattern. Connect the terms Find the hidden link between sports terms