Brian Cashman rejects Yankees' urgency narrative. So why does club appear more ruthless?

AL EastBlue JaysOriolesRaysRed SoxYankeesAL CentralGuardiansRoyalsTigersTwinsWhite SoxAL WestAngelsAstrosAthleticsMarinersRangersNL EastBravesMarlinsMetsNationalsPhilliesNL CentralBrewersCardinalsCubsPiratesRedsNL WestDiamondbacksDodgersGiantsPadresRockiesScores & ScheduleStandingsPodcastsThe Windup NewsletterFantasyMLB ProspectsMLB OddsMLB PicksPower RankingsFans Speak UpMLB Season "We are acting the same way as we did in years gone by," GM Brian Cashman said. "We just have more legitimate alternative choices to turn to. ... I don't feel like there's anything different right now." Jayne Kamin-Oncea / Imagn Images Share articleOnce Anthony Volpe completed his rehab assignment from offseason shoulder surgery, he was expected to return to the Bronx as the Yankees’ starting shortstop. Instead, his first game came in front of 4,390 fans in Worcester, Mass. — not in Yankee Stadium — a stunning development for a player the club once treated as untouchable. The Yankees opted to keep Volpe in the minors and roll at shortstop with José Caballero, who was expected to play a super-utility role but has performed well in the incumbent’s absence. Considering no Yankee has appeared in more games since 2023 than Volpe, the decision to keep him in the minors was jarring, and it reinforced the perception that the organization was operating with a new level of ruthlessness. Gone were the days of the Yankees sticking with pedigree and name recognition while underperformance lingered unchecked. General manager Brian Cashman rejects that premise. He believes the front office has followed standard operating procedure. “I know there’s this narrative that all of a sudden we woke up and smelled the coffee,” Cashman told The Athletic, “And we know it’s a must-win year — that we’re making roster moves that reflect that, and we’ve almost found a different gear. None of that is true. “We are acting the same way as we did in years gone by. We just have more legitimate alternative choices to turn to, if they present themselves. I don’t feel like there’s anything different right now.” In a sense, Cashman is right. The Yankees aren’t trying to win harder; they live by the World Series-or-bust mantra each year. The difference this season is they have the depth to challenge the status quo instead of living with it. Yankees manager Aaron Boone said the only difference he sees with the 2026 club is that it is “deeper from spot 20 to 35 on our roster,” which has allowed him and the front office to appear as if they are being more urgent than in recent years. Last season, the Yankees often had little choice but to live with their available options. Marcus Stroman and Carlos Carrasco combined for 15 starts because they lacked viable alternatives; DJ LeMahieu played 45 games; Volpe struggled for nearly the entire season as he battled a shoulder injury, and the Yankees never seriously considered benching or demoting him. Having a better roster has allowed the Yankees to make tougher decisions. A few examples: • Benching Ryan McMahon earlier in the season and having Amed Rosario play third base, even against righties. • Optioning Luis Gil to Triple A after four starts and promoting Elmer Rodríguez for his MLB debut, instead of waiting for Carlos Rodón, who made his season debut Sunday, allowing three runs in 4 1/3 innings with four strikeouts in the Yankees’ 4-3 loss to the Milwaukee Brewers. • Designating veteran outfielder Randal Grichuk for assignment, which allowed Jasson Domínguez to get everyday at-bats. • Calling up Spencer Jones for his debut after Domínguez landed on the injured list. Jones, who went 1-for-9 over the weekend, singled in the second inning Sunday for his first major-league hit and RBI. The 2026 Yankees do not have to play unappealing options because their depth has improved. Depth has given them the freedom to act on performance. “We’re not all of a sudden acting more desperate now or with more urgency,” Cashman said. “The urgency has always been there. In this current window, we have a lot of the younger players really surging. (Caballero) is obviously surging, but we still have guys like Volpe, and obviously, Elmer Rodríguez is emerging. So if Luis Gil falters, we have a legitimate alternative that allows us to say, ‘Hey, do you just want to keep going with this?’ We felt the profile that Elmer was putting forth made it make sense to make the move. It’s kind of simple. When you have the kind of depth (we have), you can play that decision-making game easier than if you didn’t.” One of the biggest takeaways through the first quarter of the season is how few holes there are on the roster. The Brewers’ sweep dropped the Yankees (26-15) out of first place in the American League East, but it doesn’t change their encouraging outlook. The starting pitching depth is such that Ryan Weathers might move to the bullpen when Gerrit Cole returns, and despite being key contributors last season, Domínguez and Volpe will have spent time in Triple A. As it was in the offseason, the bullpen remains the group that could use either internal or external improvements, and even then, it has been better than expected. “I just think we’re better,” Boone said of the overall team. “We have better depth and better options, so it’s more competition for real spots.” That competition has created uncomfortable decisions that the Yankees were previously unable, and maybe unwilling, to make. Even Aaron Judge acknowledged he was “surprised” Volpe was optioned, though he understood why the front office made that call. “It’s good to be urgent, because us as players, we’re up there fighting for our lives every single day,” Judge said last week. “We’re trying to win every single ballgame. So to see it from the management side, where it’s like, ‘Hey, we’re not gonna mess around here with some moves, we’re gonna do whatever’s best for the team,’ you appreciate seeing that as a player. But I let those guys handle that, and I’ll do what I can on the field.” Cashman pointed to the front office’s decision last season with Domínguez and Trent Grisham as proof that the club has been willing to adjust on the fly. The Yankees planned for Domínguez to be their everyday left fielder and Grisham their fourth outfielder. Instead, Grisham became the everyday center fielder and Domínguez slotted into a bench role. “Grisham was (Caballero) last year, and he maintained it all year,” Cashman said. “The plan was for Domínguez to play left field every day. But we’re trying to win, and somebody took the job from him and played better. We honored that play, but we kept him in the big leagues because we wanted his legs and thought he could play a winning role for us in that category. “I feel like every decision we make, we have a lot of discussions about it, try to make the right call, and then live with the results. It’s not really complicated, and we’re not trying to win any harder now than we did last year or the year before.” That same dynamic is now playing out between Caballero and Volpe, and it’s unclear what the latter can do to get his job back. This wasn’t planned, but it is the first year the Yankees could have realistically made this decision, considering some of the alternatives they’ve had at shortstop since 2023. For the first time in a while, the Yankees have a nearly complete team that is making observers think a philosophical shift is happening inside the organization. The Yankees may not believe that’s the case, but it’s undeniably a good thing that it’s even a conversation. Spot the pattern. Connect the terms Find the hidden link between sports terms